Human Rights Watch warns European plan for Rwanda deportation hub risks breaching international law

Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands want to send rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda from next year, but the rights group says they cannot guarantee migrants will be protected from abuse.

Traders at Nyabugogo market on the outskirts of Kigali, Rwanda, on 4 April 2024.
Traders at Nyabugogo market on the outskirts of Kigali, Rwanda, on 4 April 2024. AP Photo

Human Rights Watch (HRW) has accused five European governments of shirking their responsibilities after they unveiled plans to establish a centre in Rwanda for asylum seekers whose claims have been rejected.

Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands announced on Monday 16 November that they intend to set up a "migrant hub" in Rwanda to which failed applicants could be transferred from next year. The initiative is part of a broader European Union drive, pursued over several years, to tighten migration rules, reduce the number of people reaching the bloc to claim asylum and increase the removal of those with no right to remain. Processing or holding migrants in centres outside Europe has become a central element of that strategy.

Rights concerns

HRW argues that the European states cannot ensure that the rights of people sent to Rwanda will be respected, and that the arrangement would therefore put them in breach of their obligations under international law. The organisation says those transferred could face torture, ill-treatment, arbitrary detention and other abuses.

The group also pointed to its own difficulties in monitoring conditions in the country. In 2024, while the United Kingdom was pursuing a similar scheme of its own, the Rwandan authorities refused entry to an HRW researcher.

HRW added that the United States had deported about 20 people to Rwanda over the past year, and that little information has since emerged about where they are, the conditions in which they live or their welfare.

Share this article