Palestinian refugees born in Egypt remain treated as foreigners decades after the Nakba

In the Sharqiya village of Geziret Fadel, some 4,000 Palestinians face residency fees, school costs and paperwork that keep many out of higher education and stable work.

Palestinians at the Rafah border crossing on the Egyptian side, 28 January 2008.
Palestinians at the Rafah border crossing on the Egyptian side, 28 January 2008. AP Photo

About 4,000 Palestinian refugees live in Geziret Fadel, a village in Egypt's northern Sharqiya province, where most residents were born in Egypt yet are still classed as foreigners. Their families were among the hundreds of thousands who fled during the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, the displacement Palestinians call the Nakba.

Shamma Abu Hussein, aged about 90, may be the last villager who lived in historic Palestine. She recalls her family escaping Beersheba by camel and on foot, walking for days without food or water, and losing her mother on the way. "I remember what I went through," she said. She fears the war in Gaza, and calls by Israeli ministers for Palestinians there to be expelled, signal history repeating itself.

Barriers to education and work

Residents speak less about return than about schooling and jobs. Selmi Soliman al-Namouli, a 63-year-old farm labourer and father of 10, said three generations of his family were born in Egypt. "But when it comes to paperwork, I am treated as a foreigner," he said. Residency renewals payable in US dollars, together with school fees, meant he could not send his daughter Asmaa to university. His nephew Farid Khaled al-Namouli, 25, abandoned his studies after repeated administrative hurdles and now works in a clothing shop.

A tightening of rules

Researchers estimate about 50,000 Palestinians displaced by earlier conflicts lived in Egypt before the current Gaza war, with more than 100,000 arriving since. Under President Gamal Abdel Nasser, Palestinians enjoyed access to education and employment broadly equal to citizens, but rules were tightened after the 1978 peace treaty with Israel and the assassination of culture minister Yusuf Sibai by the Abu Nidal group. The UN agency for Palestinian refugees has never operated in Egypt.

Egyptian officials say the state provides refugees with health care and schooling and opposes their permanent displacement, and successive governments have refused naturalisation on the grounds that it could weaken the right of return. Dawn Chatty, an Oxford University emeritus professor of forced migration, said education had given Palestinians elsewhere a route to work abroad and support their families, adding: "But in Egypt, that did not happen."

Share this article